
Wow,
this is one of the most negative covers of SL I've ever read. Certainly the SL experience, especially to newbies, is an imperfect one. Granted, it takes a while to get used to maneuvering the landscape. Sure, there are many objects that cost money. But to continually complain that you can't do anything in SL without buying anything is not only wrong but misleading to the reading audience.
If you're reading this, Mr. Goldberg, understand this: I have a free account myself. I did not enter the world "naked" as you claim to have. The only thing I've had to exchange Real Dollars for Lindens to buy is my current avatar, which I consider quite a fair transaction, given how much pleasure this avatar gives me. See, while it's fine to say 'The idea of buying "virtual stuff" didn't make enough sense to me', you're making the point that only "real" objects that you can touch physically are worth paying for. Well, what about experiences? When you pay money to go to a music concert, you may choose not to buy anything, leaving the only proof you ever went being your ticket. So, did you pay money for that piece of rectangular paper? Or, did you pay for the experience of seeing and listening to a favorite band, the experience of which you cannot physically touch?
That's what SL offers: an experience. I've found that, like so much of RL, SL gives back what you put into it. If you are not a social creature, SL will seem empty to you. That's not something you can pay for; or, rather, what you pay isn't measured in dollars. As I've said, my account is free, like yours. But within a week, I realized that what SL really offers is a unique social experience, where one can be whomever one chooses, and get to meet people from all over the globe, many times people you might never have had the opportunity to meet in RL. Enjoying SL has nothing to do with money, and everything to do with your desire to make a connection.